Shopping Our Values with Phillip Haid and Caleigh Farrell

 

About This Episode

In 2025, Public Inc. asked shoppers how much a label reading "certified organic" would move them. The answer was not much.

This year they asked again, with the label rewritten to say "grown organically to be safer for you and your family." Same product, same standard, seven more words, and the claim's performance jumped. Anyone who has sat through a marketing meeting knows the rule those words break: always cut… never add. Public's CEO Phil Haid and VP of Research Caleigh Farrell have come to believe the extra words are all that matter: tell the shopper why this is good for them, today.

That would be a curiosity if the shopper were the affluent progressive we usually picture, whose numbers are supposed to be shrinking. Public's 2026 Conscious Consumer Report, built with Ipsos and Engage for Good from a survey of more than two thousand people in the U.S. and Canada, says that picture is wrong. In a year of stubborn inflation and open hostility toward anything called "woke," the people shopping their values did not behave the way all the headlines predicted. How much they earn and how they vote turn out to predict precious little. Haid's read? People want cleaner food and safer products for their own families, and they respond to whoever says how to get them plainly.

The report also takes on trust. Consumers believe business can fix big problems and doubt that it will in the same breath. The usual corporate response to that doubt is to say less. Haid and Farrell make the case that saying less is a mistake, and that the brands gaining trust right now are the ones talking openly about work they have actually done.

When so much feels uncertain, it helps to ground ourselves in what we know. What we know is that the audience is bigger and more varied than anyone assumed, and it wants to hear from you.

Also in this episode: the debut of Wider Lens, a new segment in which Carrie Fox puts a few questions to a leader in a neighboring field. First up is Johnny Flavin of Aspire Capital Advisors, a sponsor of this season, on the difference between adjusting a plan and abandoning one.

Kristine Neil

Fractional Web Partner

I'm Kristine Neil - a communications strategist who has spent 20+ years designing websites, first running a full-scale design and marketing agency, and now leading my own studio. I've been the creative director managing the work, the coder quietly fixing what others couldn't, and the strategist in the room asking why before how. Somewhere between the MBA and the other degrees, I decided web design was just one tool in a much bigger toolbox - the real work is figuring out what you're trying to say, who needs to hear it, and what's getting in the way. A website is just where all of that comes to life.

I mostly build on Squarespace, and after years deep in the platform I know how far it can go and when to push past its limits. These days, I'm especially drawn to working as a fractional partner - getting to know an organization over time and helping with whatever moves them forward, whether that's a full redesign, an ongoing hand with content and strategy, or just being the person who knows their site best. I write here about AI, UX, eCommerce, web strategy, and making the complex feel a little more human.

Contact Me

Previous
Previous

Shopping Our Values with Phillip Haid and Caleigh Farrell Part 2: Key Takeaways

Next
Next

Raising Money in the Age of Uncertainty with Dan Katz Part 2: Key Takeaways